Torn between Rogue and AA

[Gregoriovv]

I'm debating the two exhausts for my 135 (n54). Being that I am going with the Maddad mids, I am a bit worried the Active Autowerke might be a tad extreme seeing as they don't have a muffler so to speak. The Rogue has the 2 small mufflers which may keep the noise to a liveable level. I know the Maddad mids have the 2 resonators in place of the secondary cats so that should, in theory, help with the drone. Anyone out there have a similar setup that would care to chime in?

[Ultimateone]

What about the Gen 2 AA exhaust, some people have said that the Gen 1 is too loud with midpipes, and especially with catless DP.

[mike@x-ph.com]

AA Gen I is very popular for the 135i ( it might be too loud for some people).
You can also go with Gen II which sounds really good but not as loud

[arcticcat522]

Rogue if you can get one. I'm biased tho. Love mine. I don't think there are many out there since they were only made for a short time.

[Gregoriovv]

Thanks for the input! I'm still up in the air since there is one small detail that I forgot to mention, that really is trivial. I want to keep the black tail pipes instead of Crome or polished. The AA setup states they are no longer available but the Rouge site shows they are. I know, hell of a thing to decide your exhaust on, but it's a small detail that I prefer....

[Everfly]

This may make it easier for you. Do you have performance diffuser or any type beside stock ? If yes then RE is not fit probably cause the tips too short that only leave you AA.

[Gregoriovv]

Originally Posted by Everfly

This may make it easier for you. Do you have performance diffuser or any type beside stock ? If yes then RE is not fit probably cause the tips too short that only leave you AA.

No, everything is stock. Was thinking of getting a carbon fiber diffuser but that's a long way down the road.