[Zephyr15]

I agree with the previous comments about the 2008-2009 X3. The older model lacks the refinement of the new F25 X3 and is ugly to boot.

IMO, if find yourself leaning toward the X5 you should take a longer look at the MDX. I purchased a 2008 for the wife a couple months ago (she loved it and I couldn't say no due to the value). Looks good and has great features with the Tech and Entertainment packages at a significantly better price point than a similarly equipped X5. The MDX is also no performance slouch; it can't compete with the 4.8i, but it has enough power and handles and brakes well. The interior isn't something you would brag about but is still very nice, and it offers tons of head and leg room up front where you and your girl will be sitting.